What happened at the Bangalore civil court


They say it’s a black Friday. Lawyers went on rampage at the city civil court in Bangalore. Media was attacked. Public property vandalised. It was a day of good and bad. Here’s what really happened.

It all started at around 10.30 AM. Former Karnataka minister Janardhan Reddy was moments away from being brought for his case at the special CBI court. A majority of us were standing at the Canteen entrance of the court, while several other media persons were at the main entrance. A group of about 30 lawyers walked up to us and told us to leave, hurling abuses all along. It was all because of the negative publicity they received back in January when the lawyers had protested on another incident. They were here today to seek their revenge.

These lawyers were clearly agitated. They wanted us out of there. We slowly walked out, not wanting to create any trouble. They continued screaming. Hurling abuses all along. Pushing some of the cameramen. We were helpless even as the police watched on doing nothing.

Just then Janardhan Reddy had arrived. At the main entrance. We rushed to that entrance and the lawyers blocked all the media persons there as well. Pushing and throwing anything and everything they could hold on to. We were forced out of the city civil court, even as Reddy was taken inside the court.

We were all disgusted at the cops who did absolutely nothing. NOTHING. I knew that the cops could also do nothing since it is an open secret that they are obviously scared of the lawyers. We tried getting in touch with top police officials. No one responded. The media felt utterly helpless.

The lawyers continued their tirade. Pelted stones. One stone hit a cameraman of a local news channel. He was injured on his head. We shot visuals of all this, at the same time battling for our own safety. It was a confusing situation because no one really knew what to do.

Some of the local media channels decided to sit on a flash dharna, blocking traffic. This despite understanding the inconvenience it caused to the general public. Traffic was blocked for a long time. The mediapersons finally relented and went back to the court entrance. They tried preventing lawyers from entering the court premises. It was tit for tat. There was a lot of chaos till Janardhan Reddy was again being taken out of the court. The court granted his custody to CBI till March 12. The media ran to get visuals of his van leaving the court.

This was when we thought the situation was okay, and under control and that we could leave. But another altercation broke out between the lawyers and few of the media persons. The lawyers again started pushing and hurling abuses.

They started throwing anything they could find. A helmet came flying barely 2 feet from where I was standing. Next came a huge stone. Another helmet. A water bottle. And the police were requesting us to only leave. Stones were being pelted at the closest Outdoor Broadcast Van. The police used their lathis to shoo us from the scene, hoping that that would help. We were still confused about whether we should leave or not, whether we should shoot the goings on or not. That’s when more and more stones came our way. The lawyers, who till now, were hurling the stones from inside the court, slowly started moving towards us on the road.

We knew we were in trouble. That’s when we ran, literally. We fled the place. I jumped into my OB van with another reporter. Several OB vans belonging to local channels were damaged. We went up to KR circle and waited there. Most of us were feeling quite foolish, our egos hurt, that we had to run from those lawyers.

Channels had already begun broadcast of this news. It was national.

We then received information that several media persons were roughed up by the lawyers, several injured. At about 12.30 PM, when a Deputy Commissioner of Police arrived on the spot, he was hit on the head with a stone. That was probably when the police finally realised that they could no longer remain mute spectators. They finally resorted to lathi charge and fired four rounds of tear gas shells in the air. The Police Commissioner visited the spot briefly but left the scene before speaking to the media.

We were all shocked at the passive way in which the entire situation was handled. Why was no one supporting the media?

We went back to the spot to find that the situation continued to be tense. The lawyers were provoked just by our presence. Many media persons vandalised cars which belonged to lawyers, venting out their anger. One lawyer (unsure if he was part of the unruly gang) was severely kicked and thrashed by the media. And we were repeatedly being told not to film any of this. It was the most unfortunate part of the day. The media was doing exactly what we preach to others. Was violence the answer to violence? It was sheer mob mentality, rage and seething anger. All of it manifested in just the wrong way.

There was a protest at KR circle. Another lawyer was roughed up by media persons. It was ugly. A local channel reporter even prevented me from doing my recording saying nothing that the media is indulging in should be caught on camera. Not realising that some policeman on duty could very easily have captured this on one of their handy cams for evidence.

We finally went to the Vidhana Soudha, met the Home Minister. Met the CM at his residence.Most who spoke to the CM were those who were not even present at the spot when hell broke loose. There were many speakers. The CM seemed to be in his own world. By the end of the day, he ordered a judicial probe. No arrests were made still. Despite reels of footage showing the lawyers in action.

The judges who seem to have nothing to say about the lawyers who started it all, I have only one thing to say, Shame On You. You have no right to sit and deliver verdicts if you can’t control your men and stand up to the injustice. Would you watch on if you were being pelted with stones?

Black Friday

Today was a bad day for the media. Even as we were attacked and assaulted by lawyers, we had absolutely no right to stoop down to their level. Some said that that was the best way to teach them a lesson. How would it help to take these lawyers to court? These were lawyers who knew their job well. But the media, which is carrying out blackouts, and protests, should have also had some control.

The biggest faulter in all this, however, is the police. It took them close to two hours to take action. For two hours the police were motioning to us to leave the court, hoping to ensure peace. But they did nothing to control those shameless lawyers. After their DCP was hit, it seemed to have hit them as well.

None of the top police officials even responded to our calls. Most refused to come on the spot. Why were these men in uniform so hesitant to protect us? After all isn’t it their job?

Of what use is a police force, if they have to stand and watch people being abused? If they are scared of lawyers, why don’t they admit it? Why not have the armed forces man court complexes instead of the police?

The Home Minister may be in the man in charge, but he doesn’t seem man enough to take control. The city top cop should have at least stayed at the spot. After all, he isn’t a politician but a bureaucrat. While we could expect inactive behaviour from the Home Minister, why didn’t an IPS officer live up the fact that he is meant to do his job.

That said, my heart goes out to those policemen who were injured. I hear that one constable was hit by a wooden bench that was dropped from one of the top floors of the court complex.

The CM may say that every profession has both good and bad people. He needs to wake up to his senses, realise the situation, and stop making empty promises.

The media cannot be attacked and must not attack back either. The primetime debates are there for that.

As for the good that happened. It was all for Janardhan Reddy. The only one smiling.

Advertisements

Bellary ground report


On a visit to Bellary in 2011, I saw some very stark realities. One was the fact that the law of the land did not seem to matter much to those in power. Second is the amount of wealth accumulated by those who rule the roost. These are two stories culled out of a half-hour documentary that I worked on during that trip.

Reddy brothers defy SC, continue mining

Reddy brothers unaffected by Lokayukta’s report, busy in renovating family mansion

Why Baby Falak should not survive


Campaigns are being carried out, doctors are said to be working overtime, print and television media are all rooting for Baby Falak’s survival.

Even as the nation prays for this infant, I, from the bottom of my heart am praying for her not to survive.

And it’s not with a hard heart. We must understand that Falak is just a precious two years old. She is suffering from several serious infections and is barely conscious, moving in and out of an extremely critical condition to a slightly better but still critical condition. Doctors have said her chances of survival have reduced. Less than 50 percent now. And even if she survives she could end up being in a vegetative state or with severe mental problems. Falak will not be able to lead a ‘normal’ life.

In this case, is it fair for an entire nation to root for Baby Falak’s survival, especially when the reality is that she is not going to be a ‘normal’ child?

Is it fair for us to ask for a child to live despite the condition that she is in? Just because we think that every one has the right to live, we cannot assume that that is what is right, especially under such extreme medical conditions.

Baby Falak’s case is a mirror of how children, a majority of them, are living in our country. Even in urban cities like Bangalore, you can still see little children defecating on the streets. Is this what we want for our children? Is this what they deserve?

Baby Falak is struggling to breathe, with tubes attached to her. She lies in that secluded hospital bed, silently, unable to explain her pain to the rest of us. It could be the worst ever feeling. I only hope for her to have the strength to go through what she is going through.

If Falak does not have the opportunity to live a life of dignity, she definitely does not deserve to live one with tubes and needles. There is only so much that a tender body can take.

Not again, sirji!


For those of you who have read my blog on Chetan Bhagat’s column, this blog post will come as no surprise. For those of you who haven’t read it, you can read it here

Bollywood actor Abhishek Bachchan is the brand ambassador of a cellular network company. I have already taken him to task  on that in another blog post which you can read here

The latest ad for this cellular network shows a woman who is about resign from her job owing to her new born baby. Abhishek Bachchan then chides her and says she can use the cellular network’s 3G connection and still keep track of what her baby is up to at home.

Then you have a visual of the mother on her phone, watching her baby being bathed or something by a helper at home as she gives out instructions on how to put some cream or powder on the baby’s bum.

Ok, let me tell you, it is an outrageously ridiculously ad.

I thought Abhishek Bachchan will know better and do even better, especially since he himself recently became a father. Mr Bachchan, will your wife ever sit in front of her cellphone which has 3G connection, and give instructions to the bai on how to put bum cream your baby daughter? Terrible idea, sirji.

And why is any lady obliged to work or not work after she has had a baby? Doesn’t the choice lie with her and what is required for the baby? Or do you think her problem is solved through a 3G phone?

It all again comes down to the narrow-minded outlook that certain sections of society have about how women should be, what mothers should do and shouldn’t do. Disgustingly, this ad shows the mother even fall for her boss’ idea which makes it even more disrespectful.

No self-respecting mother would put herself through something like that.

Aero India 2011


I had taken these photographs during the 2011 Aero India show held in February in Bangalore. Had taken a couple of photographs but completely forgot about them especially when actor Shahid Kapoor and his father came down for the former’s F-16 cruise. Here are some of those photos. You can also see my interview with Shahid Kapoor here